Property owners and their insurers rarely accept blame quietly. A favorite defense tactic is to point the finger somewhere else: onto the attacker, onto other businesses, or onto the person who was hurt. Delaware has specific rules governing how fault is divided and what a victim can recover, and those rules can have an enormous effect on the outcome of a Wilmington case.
Modified comparative negligence
Delaware follows a system called modified comparative negligence, set out in Title 10, Section 8132 of the Delaware Code. Under that statute, an injured person can recover damages as long as their own negligence is not greater than the combined negligence of the defendants. Put another way, a victim found 50 percent or less at fault may still recover. A victim found more than 50 percent at fault recovers nothing.
When the plaintiff does bear some fault, the award is reduced proportionally. If a jury values the harm at $1 million and finds the victim 20 percent responsible, the recovery would be $800,000.
How defendants try to use it
In crime cases, defense lawyers sometimes argue that a victim walked alone at night, entered a dangerous area, got into an argument, was intoxicated, or failed to lock a door. Some of these arguments may carry weight in certain situations; many do not. Delaware juries evaluate the facts, and an owner's failure to maintain basic security can outweigh ordinary choices that anyone might make.
It is also important to remember that the attacker's intentional conduct does not automatically excuse the owner. The negligent-security claim focuses on the owner's own failure to take reasonable precautions against a foreseeable danger.
Joint-and-several liability
Delaware retains joint-and-several liability among defendants who share responsibility for the same harm. In practical terms, this can allow a victim to collect the full amount of a judgment from any responsible defendant, leaving the defendants to sort out contribution among themselves.
That rule can matter a great deal in negligent-security cases, where landlords, management firms, and guard vendors frequently divide responsibility, and where some parties may have limited insurance or assets. It reduces the risk that a seriously injured victim is left undercompensated because one responsible party cannot pay its share.
No cap on compensatory damages
Unlike some states, Delaware sets no general dollar limit on compensatory awards when the claim sounds in ordinary negligence. That means a jury can award what it finds the evidence supports for:
- Past and future medical care, including surgery, rehabilitation, and psychological treatment
- Missed paychecks and a diminished capacity to work going forward
- Pain, suffering, and emotional distress
- Disfigurement and permanent impairment
For families, a wrongful-death claim can recover funeral expenses and compensation for the loss of financial support and companionship.
Other rules, such as those that may apply to claims against government entities, can be different, which is one reason to have a lawyer evaluate who the potential defendants are.
Building a case that withstands blame-shifting
Strong evidence of the owner's failures is the best answer to arguments about the victim's conduct. That evidence may include records of prior crimes on or near the property, maintenance logs showing broken locks or lights, staffing records showing absent guards, and testimony from security professionals describing the safeguards a prudent operator would have used. Delaware's foreseeability standard, which considers the totality of prior incidents rather than requiring an identical earlier crime, helps put that evidence in context.
Multiple attackers and multiple failures
Some incidents involve more than one assailant or more than one security breakdown, such as a broken gate that let a group onto a property and an absent guard who never called for help. Delaware's rules allow a jury to consider each party's share of the overall fault, while joint-and-several liability helps ensure the injured person is not left bearing the cost of gaps between defendants.
What Wilmington victims should avoid
Insurance adjusters may call soon after an incident and ask for a recorded statement. Offhand comments about why you were at the property or what you had been doing can later be used to argue comparative fault. Speaking with a lawyer first is usually the wiser course.
The firm and its Delaware arrangement
The Haggard Law Firm is a Coral Gables practice devoted largely to negligent security. Michael A. Haggard is licensed in Florida; he lacks a Delaware license. When handling a Delaware claim, he works in partnership with a locally admitted attorney and, if permitted by court rules, seeks pro hac vice status in that single lawsuit.
Of the nearly 500 negligent-security matters the firm has handled, its largest result was $102.7 million at trial, never exceeded by another American jury in this field; the figure is gross.
Funds must be recovered before any attorney's fee is due. For a confidential talk that costs nothing, ring (305) 446-5700.
Attorney advertising. The example figures above are hypothetical and illustrate how Delaware's rules work in general; this is not legal advice. Reaching out leaves you under no obligation and forms no engagement by default. Mr. Haggard is licensed in Florida. Previous results are not a guarantee.


