Picture a Texas jury hearing a case about a woman shot in a dimly lit apartment parking lot. The jurors agree the owner ignored months of warnings. Yet they also know someone else pulled the trigger. How Texas asks those jurors to divide responsibility can change the value of a claim by hundreds of thousands of dollars or more.
The rules come mostly from Chapter 33 of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code, which the state calls proportionate responsibility.
Step one: the victim's own percentage
Texas uses a modified comparative-fault approach with a 51 percent bar. If the jury decides the injured person was more than half responsible, the person recovers nothing. At 50 percent or less, the award is reduced by the victim's share. So a victim assigned 10 percent of the blame recovers 90 percent of the damages found, subject to the rules below.
Defense lawyers sometimes try to shift blame by pointing to the victim's choices: walking alone at night, arguing with the attacker, or ignoring a posted warning. Careful preparation of the timeline and the surrounding circumstances helps keep that percentage low.
Step two: assigning a share to the attacker
Texas allows a defendant to ask the court to designate other people as responsible third parties, even if they are not parties to the lawsuit. In negligent-security cases, the property owner almost always seeks to designate the shooter or attacker. Chapter 33 includes a mechanism for naming an unidentified criminal as well, provided the defendant follows strict procedural requirements.
Once a responsible third party is designated, the jury can apportion a percentage of responsibility to that person. That share usually cannot be collected from anyone, because the attacker is typically uninsured or judgment-proof.
Step three: joint and several liability
Generally, a defendant in Texas pays only its own percentage. A major exception applies when that defendant's share is greater than 50 percent: in that case, it can be held jointly and severally liable for the full amount of the damages awarded against defendants. Chapter 33 also contains a separate provision under which certain intentional criminal acts by a defendant trigger joint liability, but that provision usually concerns the criminal actor, not the owner.
Why the allocation matters so much
Consider a hypothetical in which a jury finds $2 million in damages. If it assigns 60 percent to the property owner, 35 percent to the gunman, and 5 percent to the victim, the owner's share exceeds 50 percent and the owner may be jointly liable for the $1.9 million attributable to the defendants. If instead the jury assigns 40 percent to the owner and 55 percent to the gunman, the owner's exposure generally drops to $800,000.
Real cases are more complex, but the example shows why plaintiffs focus so heavily on the property's role.
Evidence that strengthens the owner's share
- Prior crimes satisfying the Timberwalk factors of proximity, recency, frequency, similarity, and publicity
- Proof that inexpensive measures would have deterred or prevented the attack, addressing the unreasonable-risk requirement from UDR Texas Properties, L.P. v. Petrie
- Internal admissions, such as emails recognizing a security problem
- Expert testimony linking specific failures, like a disabled gate or absent guard, to the attacker's access
How juries hear the allocation question
At the end of trial, the judge gives jurors a verdict form listing each defendant, each designated third party, and the victim, with a blank beside each name for a percentage. The percentages must total 100. Jurors often begin with a gut sense that the person who used the weapon is most to blame. Effective presentation helps them see that a property owner who sat on known risks for months made the attack possible in a way the jury can measure.
Deadlines still control everything
None of this matters if a claim is filed too late. Texas typically closes the door on injury suits two years after the attack, and on death claims two years after the passing.
A firm with deep allocation experience
The Haggard firm, based in Coral Gables, has litigated nearly 500 negligent-security matters nationwide, including the trial in which jurors returned $102.7 million, a result the firm describes as unmatched in U.S. negligent-security history; that number is gross. Michael A. Haggard's sole bar admission is in Florida; Texas has not licensed him. In Texas, he co-counsels with a Texas-admitted attorney and, if the judge permits, may receive the court's pro hac vice approval covering that one dispute. The Texas lawyer stays on the team for the duration.
Attorney's fees are contingent on recovery. To talk privately and at no cost about a Texas incident, call (305) 446-5700 or visit Picture a Texas jury hearing a case about a woman shot in a dimly lit apartment parking lot. The jurors agree the owner ignored months of warnings. Yet they also know someone else pulled the trigger. How Texas asks those jurors to divide responsibility can change the value of a claim by hundreds of thousands of dollars or more.
The rules come mostly from Chapter 33 of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code, which the state calls proportionate responsibility.
Step one: the victim's own percentage
Texas uses a modified comparative-fault approach with a 51 percent bar. If the jury decides the injured person was more than half responsible, the person recovers nothing. At 50 percent or less, the award is reduced by the victim's share. So a victim assigned 10 percent of the blame recovers 90 percent of the damages found, subject to the rules below.
Defense lawyers sometimes try to shift blame by pointing to the victim's choices: walking alone at night, arguing with the attacker, or ignoring a posted warning. Careful preparation of the timeline and the surrounding circumstances helps keep that percentage low.
Step two: assigning a share to the attacker
Texas allows a defendant to ask the court to designate other people as responsible third parties, even if they are not parties to the lawsuit. In negligent-security cases, the property owner almost always seeks to designate the shooter or attacker. Chapter 33 includes a mechanism for naming an unidentified criminal as well, provided the defendant follows strict procedural requirements.
Once a responsible third party is designated, the jury can apportion a percentage of responsibility to that person. That share usually cannot be collected from anyone, because the attacker is typically uninsured or judgment-proof.
Step three: joint and several liability
Generally, a defendant in Texas pays only its own percentage. A major exception applies when that defendant's share is greater than 50 percent: in that case, it can be held jointly and severally liable for the full amount of the damages awarded against defendants. Chapter 33 also contains a separate provision under which certain intentional criminal acts by a defendant trigger joint liability, but that provision usually concerns the criminal actor, not the owner.
Why the allocation matters so much
Consider a hypothetical in which a jury finds $2 million in damages. If it assigns 60 percent to the property owner, 35 percent to the gunman, and 5 percent to the victim, the owner's share exceeds 50 percent and the owner may be jointly liable for the $1.9 million attributable to the defendants. If instead the jury assigns 40 percent to the owner and 55 percent to the gunman, the owner's exposure generally drops to $800,000.
Real cases are more complex, but the example shows why plaintiffs focus so heavily on the property's role.
Evidence that strengthens the owner's share
- Prior crimes satisfying the Timberwalk factors of proximity, recency, frequency, similarity, and publicity
- Proof that inexpensive measures would have deterred or prevented the attack, addressing the unreasonable-risk requirement from UDR Texas Properties, L.P. v. Petrie
- Internal admissions, such as emails recognizing a security problem
- Expert testimony linking specific failures, like a disabled gate or absent guard, to the attacker's access
How juries hear the allocation question
At the end of trial, the judge gives jurors a verdict form listing each defendant, each designated third party, and the victim, with a blank beside each name for a percentage. The percentages must total 100. Jurors often begin with a gut sense that the person who used the weapon is most to blame. Effective presentation helps them see that a property owner who sat on known risks for months made the attack possible in a way the jury can measure.
Deadlines still control everything
None of this matters if a claim is filed too late. Texas typically closes the door on injury suits two years after the attack, and on death claims two years after the passing.
A firm with deep allocation experience
The Haggard firm, based in Coral Gables, has litigated nearly 500 negligent-security matters nationwide, including the trial in which jurors returned $102.7 million, a result the firm describes as unmatched in U.S. negligent-security history; that number is gross. Michael A. Haggard's sole bar admission is in Florida; Texas has not licensed him. In Texas, he co-counsels with a Texas-admitted attorney and, if the judge permits, may receive the court's pro hac vice approval covering that one dispute. The Texas lawyer stays on the team for the duration.
Attorney's fees are contingent on recovery. To talk privately and at no cost about a Texas incident, call (305) 446-5700.
Attorney advertising. The fault-allocation rules described above are simplified and the numbers are illustrative only; this is general information, not counsel, and an inquiry by phone or form is not an engagement. Mr. Haggard holds Florida admission only. Prior verdicts do not predict future ones.
.Attorney advertising. The fault-allocation rules described above are simplified and the numbers are illustrative only; this is general information, not counsel, and an inquiry by phone or form is not an engagement. Mr. Haggard holds Florida admission only. Prior verdicts do not predict future ones.


